Motherland, Vineeta Vijayaraghavan, 4/50
Jun. 7th, 2009 10:34 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Cross-posted to
50books_poc
Maya used to go back to India every year; she was born there, and raised by her grandmother until she was four, when her parents took her back with them to New York. But she's now 15, with commitments to her American school, friends, and unsuitable boyfriend, and this extended holiday is forced on her by her parents as a way of cutting at least some of these ties. Initially reluctant, Maya gradually settles back into her life in India; but things here have changed as well, even if they initially look the same.
I liked this - it's a nice, slow story, with a lot of acute observation (including many great descriptions of food), and the careful unwinding of relationships within Maya's extended family is fascinating, with all the characters vivid and credible. Maya feels like a real teenager, and one with varying commitments and strengths from both her Indian and American upbringings; she's at home with some things and confused by others, whether language or social custom or political opinion. She is privileged, and self-centred, but she does try to do something about the latter, and again it feels appropriate for a 15 year old, and the other characters have their own blindspots. The novel's only weak point is the subplot involving the Tamil Tigers (the story's set just after Rajiv Ghandi's assassination) as while things like the interview at Customs work as background, subsequent developments don't feel organic to the text, with an odd lack of emotional reaction or foreseeable consequences. What works in the story is how Maya perceives herself and others, though, and how it changes over time.
It doesn't look as though she's published anything else yet, unfortunately.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
Maya used to go back to India every year; she was born there, and raised by her grandmother until she was four, when her parents took her back with them to New York. But she's now 15, with commitments to her American school, friends, and unsuitable boyfriend, and this extended holiday is forced on her by her parents as a way of cutting at least some of these ties. Initially reluctant, Maya gradually settles back into her life in India; but things here have changed as well, even if they initially look the same.
I liked this - it's a nice, slow story, with a lot of acute observation (including many great descriptions of food), and the careful unwinding of relationships within Maya's extended family is fascinating, with all the characters vivid and credible. Maya feels like a real teenager, and one with varying commitments and strengths from both her Indian and American upbringings; she's at home with some things and confused by others, whether language or social custom or political opinion. She is privileged, and self-centred, but she does try to do something about the latter, and again it feels appropriate for a 15 year old, and the other characters have their own blindspots. The novel's only weak point is the subplot involving the Tamil Tigers (the story's set just after Rajiv Ghandi's assassination) as while things like the interview at Customs work as background, subsequent developments don't feel organic to the text, with an odd lack of emotional reaction or foreseeable consequences. What works in the story is how Maya perceives herself and others, though, and how it changes over time.
It doesn't look as though she's published anything else yet, unfortunately.